Stock Perps Lawsuit: Judge Says CFTC Likely Overstepped as Jump, DRW and Coinbase Back It
In the stock perps lawsuit, Judge Caproni sees the CFTC likely overstepping. Jump, DRW, Coinbase and Kalshi filed to defend the approvals.
$ Stop reading delayed data. Read live order book depth on the 100 most liquid Hyperliquid pairs right now.
Launch Free Terminal →The stock perps lawsuit now has a judge's preliminary view on the record, and it does not favor the CFTC. U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni refused on November 3 to halt trading in US single-stock perpetual futures, but found the challengers "likely to succeed on the merits" of their claim that the agency lacked authority to approve them, CoinPaprika reported. A week later, six firms including Jump Trading and DRW asked to file an amicus brief defending the approvals.
For perp traders the question is no longer only whether US stock perps survive. It is which side of the market wants them, why the largest liquidity providers lined up behind the CFTC, and what a preliminary injunction would change for where single-stock perp flow trades.
Where the stock perps lawsuit stands after the first ruling
The case is Capital Markets Alliance Association v. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, No. 1:26-cv-09608 in the Southern District of New York, according to The Cryptonomist. The alliance, whose members include Cboe Global Markets, Citadel Securities and the Healthy Markets Association, filed on November 3, FinanceFeeds reported, naming the CFTC and Chairman Michael Selig as defendants.
Caproni denied the temporary restraining order because the alliance had not shown actual and imminent irreparable harm. On the other factors she went the other way: she found the group likely to succeed on its claim that the CFTC exceeded its statutory authority, and held that the balance of equities and public interest favored the challengers, per FinanceFeeds. The Cryptonomist reports she questioned whether contracts with no delivery of a security on a set future date can meet the definition of a security future, and suggested they look more like security-based swaps.
Those are preliminary findings, not a ruling on the case. But a judge who has already written that the plaintiffs are likely to win on the merits is the same judge deciding the preliminary injunction.
The amicus coalition: Coinbase, Kalshi, Payward, Jump, DRW and Paradigm
Coinbase, Kalshi and Payward, the parent of Kraken, asked the court on Monday, November 10, for leave to file an amicus brief backing the CFTC, with DRW Holdings, Jump Trading and Paradigm on the same motion, The Block reported.
Their core argument is definitional. The firms wrote that a security future "by definition" cannot be a swap, and argued that the Commodity Exchange Act lets a contract without a fixed expiry fit the security futures framework, per The Cryptonomist. They point to standardized terms, margin requirements and central clearing, to funding payments that tie the contract price to the stock, and to the joint CFTC and SEC oversight that already governs security futures.
They also pushed back on the idea that the SEC was sidelined, saying the agency was "at the table from the very start" and that the two regulators jointly sought public comment on classification, according to The Block. Coinbase Vice Chairman Ryan VanGrack said: "The U.S. should lead, not cede, this space." On the other side, alliance secretary Adam Ford said the rollout "erodes investor protection," FinanceFeeds reported.
Why market makers are backing the CFTC
The names on the amicus motion split into two groups. Coinbase, Kalshi and Payward own the venues: Coinbase Derivatives, KalshiEX and Bitnomial Exchange filed on September 18 to list perps on large-cap US stocks, and the filings were deemed approved on November 2 under CFTC Regulation 40.3, without a separate approval order, per FinanceFeeds. Payward acquired Bitnomial earlier this year, The Cryptonomist noted.
DRW, Jump and Paradigm are a different kind of participant. The Cryptonomist describes them as firms with existing or potential interests in trading equity perps. Onchain data shows what that looks like in practice: on Hyperliquid's HIP-3 Nvidia market, the largest non-directional position on November 12 was a Jump short of 348,000 NVDA, about $56 million, and market makers held 70% of total short open interest, BlockBeats reported via KuCoin.
That is the structural point. The liquidity providers that already quote single-stock perps offshore want an onshore venue with US customers. The plaintiffs, Cboe and Citadel Securities among them, run businesses in listed and traded equities and options, the instruments a stock perp competes with for the same directional demand. The legal argument is about swaps and futures. The economic argument is about which venue captures retail single-stock exposure.
What a preliminary injunction would change
The court has not ruled on whether to block the products while the case runs. The CFTC's opposition to the preliminary injunction was due November 6 and the alliance's reply on November 10, subject to the judge's discretion, CoinPaprika reported. No hearing date has been reported.
If Caproni grants the injunction, the approvals for the three US venues are suspended while the case continues. The case itself only covers those approvals, so offshore markets such as Hyperliquid's HIP-3 books are not parties. In practice, a pause onshore leaves the existing offshore order books as the only continuous single-stock perp markets. Buildix covered that tension when the suit was filed in Equity Perps Lawsuit: Cboe and Citadel-Backed Group Sues the CFTC.
If she denies it, the products keep trading but under a judge who has signaled doubt about the legal basis. That is a weak foundation for a venue to build deep liquidity on. Market makers can quote, but committing balance sheet to a product that a court may later reclassify as a security-based swap is a different calculation.
A separate date sits on the calendar: comments on the CFTC's crypto market rulemaking close on December 14, per FinanceFeeds. The perps case and the broader rulemaking are on parallel tracks, and an adverse ruling in one will shape the comment file in the other.
Reading the flow while the court decides
The useful signals are on the order books, not in the docket. Watch whether HIP-3 single-stock perp open interest keeps growing in the days around the injunction decision. Rising open interest offshore after an injunction would show US-adjacent demand rerouting to the venues that remain open. Watch also whether the market maker share of short open interest changes: if the same firms that signed the amicus brief cut offshore inventory, that is a sign they expect an onshore venue to win the flow.
The Buildix screener tracks HIP-3 stock perps next to crypto perps with open interest, funding and CVD per pair, and the whale tracker follows the large wallets as they resize.
Caproni's preliminary view and the amicus coalition have drawn the lines clearly: perp venues and trading firms on one side, Cboe and Citadel Securities on the other. The injunction ruling decides where single-stock perp liquidity concentrates for the months the case takes, and that flow will show up on the order books before it shows up in a court opinion.